February 21, 2024

The Nerve Archive

Where Government Gets Exposed

MY LAST NERVE: Lawmakers and judges get awfully cozy


south carolina judicial department, judiciary

It’s all in the family

The Judicial Merit Selection Commission began meeting this week to vet judges for seats around South Carolina, marking the bi-annual migration of judicial candidates to the statehouse. That’s where the problem lies: would-be judges are kowtowing to lawmakers again.

On the road to a state judgeship, the first stop is a vetting at the JMSC, a panel composed of six legislators and four other citizens appointed by legislators. It’s the same commission where former speaker Bobby Harrell placed his brother.

South Carolina is one of only two states where legislators control judicial screening. That’s why the American Bar Association says we don’t appoint judges by merit.

It’s not unusual here to find former legislators with little or no experience on the bench making their way to higher courts. Former Supreme Court Chief Justice Jean Toal was a longtime legislator with no prior judicial experience.

Lawyer-legislators on the JMSC have participated in questioning and voted favorably on judges that they practice in front of.  Challenges to the constitutionally of the JMSC have been shot down in state courts.

Three candidates per seat are approved by the JMSC. Then the statehouse becomes a hive of handshaking and backslapping, with potential judges cozying up to legislators. For some candidates, the support comes easier because they’re relatives of legislators. Supreme Court Justice Kaye Hearn’s husband, George Hearn, was a house member when she was elected to the Supreme Court.

When the JMSC meets on Dec. 1, one of the candidates for Administrative Law court will be Milton Kimpson, Senator Marlon Kimpson’s brother. If the JMSC approves him, his brother’s position will, it’s fair to say, make it likelier that he’ll be elected by the legislature.

Then, when the time for reelecting judges comes, the process starts all over again with the JMSC hearing, the handshaking, the backslapping and the voting.

In a state that claims to have three branches of government, South Carolina really doesn’t. Equal justice can get lost somewhere in the statehouse.


We need your help to continue our mission of holding government officials accountable! As part of the South Carolina Policy Council, a nonprofit, nonpartisan research organization, we rely on donations to operate. Please consider giving today so we can keep bringing accountability to government. It’s your power, and it’s time to take it back!
The Nerve